Every Indianapolis homeowner has heard the horror stories. The contractor who took the deposit and disappeared. The project that dragged on for months. The "finished" work that needed to be redone.

Finding a reliable contractor doesn't have to be a gamble. Here's how to find one you can trust.

Where to Find Contractor Candidates

Word of Mouth

Still the most reliable starting point. Ask:

Neighbors who've done similar projects
Friends and family in the Indy area
Coworkers who own homes
Your real estate agent
Local building supply stores

When asking for referrals:

Was the project completed on time?
Were there any problems? How were they handled?
Was the final price close to the estimate?
Would they hire them again?

Online Sources

Useful for research:

Google reviews (look for patterns, not just ratings)
Better Business Bureau
Houzz and Angi (read reviews critically)
Next door recommendations

Be cautious of:

Ads that appear at the top of search results
"Too good to be true" reviews
Companies with no online presence at all

Professional Associations

Indianapolis-area contractors may belong to:

Indiana Builders Association
NARI (National Association of the Remodeling Industry)
Local trade associations

Membership doesn't guarantee quality, but it shows some level of professional commitment.

The Vetting Process

Step 1: Initial Screening

Before meeting in person, gather basic information:

Ask by phone:

How long have you been in business?
Are you licensed and insured?
Do you handle projects like mine?
Can you provide references?

Eliminate anyone who:

Is evasive about questions
Can't provide insurance information
Doesn't return calls promptly
Pressures you to decide immediately

Step 2: Verify Credentials

For remaining candidates, verify:

Insurance:

General liability (call the insurer to verify)
Workers' compensation
Auto liability

Business legitimacy:

Registered with Indiana Secretary of State
Local registration (if required)
Physical business address

Trade licenses:

Electrical work requires state license
Plumbing requires state license
Verify through Indiana Professional Licensing Agency

Step 3: Check References

Don't skip this step. Actually call references.

Questions to ask:

What work did they do for you?
Were you satisfied with the quality?
Did they stay on budget?
Did they meet the timeline?
Were there any problems? How did they handle them?
Would you hire them again?

Red flags in references:

Contractor provides only recent references
References are vague or hesitant
Multiple mentions of the same problems

Step 4: Get Multiple Bids

Get at least three written estimates for any project over $1,000.

What bids should include:

Detailed scope of work
Materials to be used (brand, quality level)
Timeline for completion
Payment schedule
Warranty information

Comparing bids:

Don't automatically choose the lowest
Be suspicious if one bid is much lower than others
Make sure you're comparing the same scope

Warning Signs During the Process

Red Flags at First Contact

Won't provide proof of insurance
Only accepts cash
Pressures you to decide today
No physical business address
Can't provide references

Red Flags During Bidding

Bid is significantly lower than competitors
Bid is vague about materials or scope
Unwilling to put details in writing
Wants large deposit before starting
Can't explain their process

Red Flags About Their History

Multiple BBB complaints
Pattern of negative reviews
Hasn't been in business long
Works under multiple business names
History of liens against them

Questions to Ask Before Hiring

About Their Business

How long have you been operating?
Who will actually do the work?
Do you use subcontractors? Who?
What's your typical timeline for this type of project?

About Your Project

Have you done projects like this before?
What challenges do you anticipate?
What permits will be needed?
How do you handle changes to the scope?

About the Contract

What exactly is included?
What's not included that I should know about?
What's your warranty?
How do you handle disputes?

The Contract

Never start work without a written contract.

Must-Have Contract Elements

Detailed scope of work
Specific materials to be used
Total price and payment schedule
Start date and expected completion date
Permit responsibilities
Change order process
Warranty terms
Termination clause

Contract Red Flags

Vague language about scope
No payment schedule
No timeline
Requires full payment upfront
No warranty mentioned
Contractor resistant to putting things in writing

Indianapolis-Specific Considerations

Permits

Many projects in Indianapolis require permits from the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services. Your contractor should pull permits for:

Structural changes
Electrical work
Plumbing work
HVAC work
Significant additions

Important: If a contractor suggests skipping permits, that's a major red flag.

Seasonal Considerations

Indianapolis weather affects project timing:

Exterior work is best spring through fall
Concrete has temperature limitations
Some indoor projects are better for winter

A reliable contractor will advise you on the best timing for your project.

When to Consider Professional Help

Finding and vetting contractors takes time and expertise. You might miss red flags that professionals catch immediately.

Consider getting help if:

You're planning a major renovation
You've been burned by contractors before
You don't have time to thoroughly vet candidates
The project involves multiple trades

Vetted Crews helps Indianapolis homeowners find reliable contractors. We verify credentials, check references, and ensure you're working with professionals who will deliver quality work.

Call (317) 850-8396 to learn how we can protect your next project.

Don't gamble on your home. Find contractors you can trust.

How to Find a Reliable Contractor in Indianapolis: A Homeowner's Guide

In This Article